Brooklyn Nine-Nine may have ended, but its legacy lives on. The hilarious and heartwarming police sitcom built a devoted fanbase over the years, and now, there’s exciting news—a brand-new spinoff series is in the works!
While details are still under wraps, one thing is certain: fans are already buzzing with speculation about what it could be about.
But before diving into the future of the Nine-Nine, let’s talk about its past. Throughout its eight-season run, Brooklyn Nine-Nine delivered countless iconic moments, but not all of them were universally loved.
Some episodes sparked intense debates among fans, with arguments ranging from plot choices to character decisions.
Here are three Brooklyn Nine-Nine episodes that still have fans divided.
The Finale: Was It a Perfect Send-Off or a Letdown?
Series finales are tricky—some shows get it right, while others leave fans wanting more. Brooklyn Nine-Nine’s final episode, The Last Day, tried to wrap things up with one last elaborate heist and emotional goodbyes. But did it succeed?
For some fans, the finale was a perfect farewell. It captured everything the show was about—humor, heart, and unpredictable hijinks.
Seeing Jake Peralta step away from the force for his family felt like a natural evolution of his character. Plus, the callbacks to past episodes were a treat for long-time viewers.
However, others weren’t so convinced. Some felt that the humor overshadowed the emotional weight of the ending.
A few fans were also disappointed by certain character arcs, particularly Rosa’s decision to remain distant from the squad. And let’s not forget those who wished there had been more closure for Gina, who had left the series earlier.
So, was The Last Day a perfect ending? Or did it leave too many loose ends? Fans are still debating this one.
The Boyle Family Episode: Hilarious or Too Over-the-Top?
If there’s one thing Brooklyn Nine-Nine did well, it was its ability to take a running joke and push it to its limits. Enter The Boyle-Linetti Wedding, an episode that went all-in on the bizarre world of the Boyle family.
Charles Boyle had always been portrayed as quirky and overly affectionate, but this episode took things to another level.
His entire family shared the same soft-spoken voice, love for mayonnaise-based dishes, and an eerie closeness that made even Jake uncomfortable.
For some viewers, this episode was pure comedic gold. It leaned into the absurdity of the Boyle family dynamic and delivered some of the show’s most ridiculous moments.
However, others felt it was too exaggerated, almost turning the Boyles into caricatures rather than actual characters.
Was this episode peak Brooklyn Nine-Nine humor, or did it go too far? The debate rages on.
The Valloweaster Heist: The Best or Worst Heist Episode?
The Halloween Heists became a legendary tradition on Brooklyn Nine-Nine, with each season delivering a more elaborate and chaotic competition. But Valloweaster—the season 7 heist episode—divided fans like no other.
Unlike previous heists, which took place in a single night, this one stretched across multiple holidays: Valentine’s Day, Easter, and Halloween.
The result? A heist that spanned nearly a year, with twists and betrayals happening over an extended period.
Some fans loved the change in format, praising the unpredictability and the creative storytelling. Others, however, felt that it lost the magic of a traditional heist episode.
By spreading the competition across three separate events, the tension and excitement of a single-night showdown were somewhat diluted.
So, did Valloweaster refresh the heist concept, or did it break what wasn’t broken? It’s a hot topic among the Nine-Nine faithful.
What These Episodes Say About Brooklyn 99’s Legacy
One of the reasons Brooklyn Nine-Nine remains so beloved is because it took risks. Not every episode was a hit with every fan, but that’s part of what made it special—it was a show willing to experiment, push boundaries, and evolve over time.
The spinoff series will have big shoes to fill. Whether it follows old characters or introduces a new precinct, one thing is certain: fans will be watching, analyzing, and debating every episode just like they did with the original.
Conclusion
While Brooklyn Nine-Nine had its fair share of universally loved episodes, some moments still divide fans.
Whether it was the series finale, the absurdity of the Boyle family, or the controversial heist episode, these debates keep the show’s legacy alive.
As we look forward to the upcoming spinoff, one question remains—will it be able to capture the magic of the original while delivering fresh, debate-worthy moments? Only time will tell. Until then, Nine-Nine!
Frequently Asked Questions
Will the Brooklyn 99 spinoff bring back the original cast?
There’s no official confirmation yet, but fans are hopeful that at least some of the original characters will make appearances.
What could the Brooklyn 99 spinoff be about?
Speculation suggests it could follow another police precinct, a different law enforcement agency, or even focus on a fan-favorite character like Holt or Gina.
Why do fans debate the Brooklyn 99 finale?
Some loved the humor and callbacks, while others felt it lacked emotional closure for certain characters.
Was the Boyle family episode too exaggerated?
Some fans found it hilarious, while others thought it went too far in making the Boyles seem overly bizarre.
Which Halloween heist episode was the best?
It depends on who you ask! Many fans love the earlier heists, while others enjoy the later, more complex ones.
Did Rosa get a satisfying ending?
Fans are split—some appreciate her independence, while others wanted more closure in her relationships.
Why was Gina’s character written out of the show?
Chelsea Peretti, who played Gina, decided to leave, but she made a few guest appearances later.
Will Brooklyn 99 ever return for a revival?
Nothing is confirmed, but given the show’s popularity, a revival or reunion isn’t out of the question.
Did Valloweaster ruin the heist tradition?
Some think it was a fun twist, while others believe it lost the magic of a single-night heist.
What made Brooklyn 99 so special?
Its mix of comedy, heart, and diverse representation set it apart from other sitcoms, making it a fan favorite for years.